Up@dawn 2.0

Saturday, April 24, 2021

B.P. Blood's "gray gull" revelation

"It is no surprise to hear that James was influenced by Emerson. James has the same optative ebullience, the same metaphorical panache, the same bedrock faith in the individual. Nor is it surprising that John Stuart Mill would be a long-standing influence on James. Utilitarianism was stepfather to pragmatism and to its concern with results, with “fruits not roots.” No active thinker in the mid- to late nineteenth century could easily escape the shadows cast by Emerson and Mill. But almost everyone except William James escaped the influence of Benjamin Paul Blood, whose pamphlet The Anaesthetic Revelation James read and reviewed a few months after the Emerson party in Concord.18 Blood was a writer of letters to newspapers. Ten years older than James, he was a nonacademic, a philosopher, a mystic, and, it would turn out, a pluralist to boot. Blood had been born in 1832 in Amsterdam, New York, just west of Schenectady. He went to Union College, then returned home to the “large brick house on the south side of the Mohawk as you enter Amsterdam from the East.”19 Blood had heard or read Henry James Sr., and he credited him as “the first to impress me with the presence of that transcendent [quality] we call genius.” Blood was, delightfully, much more than a metaphysician. Interested in machinery, he had patented a “swathing reaper.” He had been a gambler, making and losing, he told James, “bar’ls” of money. He had been a “fancy gymnast” and had fought “some heavy fights—notably one of forty minutes with Ed. Mullett, whom I left senseless.” “I have worn out many styles,” he wrote James years later, “and am cosmopolitan, liberal to others, and contented with myself.” If Blood sounded like Whitman, he looked like a cross between Poe and Nietzsche. He sent James a photo of himself at age twenty-eight, taken when he had just “lifted by a chain on my right shoulder and around my right arm 1160 lbs.” “I never could value things at others’ rates,” Blood wrote James, “never was respectable or conforming . . . The chaff blows off, the grain remains and I could borrow the city treasury if I wanted the money.”20 In 1875 this Paul Bunyan of Amsterdam, New York, sent William James a pamphlet announcing the discovery of “a mystical substitute for the answer which philosophy seeks, [an] ontological intuition, beyond the power of words to tell of, which one experiences while taking nitrous oxide gas and other anaesthetics.”21 Blood located the moment of insight not in the instant of “going under,” not in the swirling down the ever-accelerating, ever-darkening red whirlpool one remembers from a childhood tonsillectomy, but in the moment of “recall from anaesthetic stupor to sensible observation, or ‘coming-to,’ in which the genius of being is revealed” (Blood’s italics). The awakening moment, with its “primeval prestige” and “all but appalling solemnity,” solved the world’s mystery. “This world,” Blood wrote and James quoted, “is no more that alien terror which was taught me. Spurning the cloud-grimed and still sultry battlements whence so lately Jehovan thunders boomed, my gray gull lifts her wing against the nightfall, and takes the dim leagues with a fearless eye.”22 Perhaps Blood’s prose stirred memories for James of the gulls at the mouth of the Amazon. At any rate, he compared the state Blood described to “Nirwana” and to what was suggested by the old proverb In vino Veritas. “Ontological emotion, however stumbled on, has something authoritative for the individual who feels it,” James wrote, adding, “The duty of the intellect toward it is not suppression but interpretation.” James did not think that laughing gas was necessarily the best way of getting at the revelation in question. “What blunts the mind and weakens the will,” he wrote, “is no full channel for truth.” He preferred, he was careful to say, “the intoxication of moral volition.”23 The essence of it for Blood was the discovery that “fulness of life . . . forestalls the need of philosophy,” that life itself is a “sufficiency, to which . . . a wonder or fear of why it is sufficient cannot pertain, and could be attributed to it only as an impossible disease or lack.” This repose in the sufficiency of life, the rejection of the fundamental lack or dearth, is at the opposite pole from the core convictions of William’s father, whose best prose is a hectic poetry of dearth. “The secret of Being,” as James summarized Blood, “is not in the dark immensity beyond knowledge, but at home, this side, beneath the feet and overlooked by knowledge.”24 James was attracted to Blood’s energy, his forceful reasoning, his idiosyncratic boldness, his unconventional defense of an altered mental state. He also liked Blood’s conclusion, and he especially admired his writing. Blood was, said James, “a man with extraordinary power over the English tongue.”25 Blood talked about “pounding and punching the chaos into the logos,” and his writing swoops and soars in a sort of blind onward rapture. “And does not pluralism have in it its own negation,” Blood wrote James in 1897, “as the many (per se) must afford a specimen of the one. The world has long believed in limited space (subjective), unity of intelligence, community, a home, a heaven, a duty, an order, a chance for fame that is known of all, not a world, but the world, under control—all facts and possibilities known and realized—imperial peace.” Who could resist a man who talked like that? “You have the greatest gift of superior gab since Shakespeare,” a delighted William James wrote Blood.26 James’s interest in people like Blood—figures from the intellectual underworld—exasperated his professional colleagues even as it moved them, sometimes, to admiration. James’s judgment, said one, was “corrupted by kindness.” George Santayana, first a student of James, then a colleague and rival, and finally a eulogist, said James “kept his mind and heart wide open to all that might seem, to polite minds, odd, personal, or visionary in religion and philosophy. He gave a sincerely respectful hearing to sentimentalists, mystics, spiritualists, wizards, cranks, quacks, and imposters . . . He thought, with his usual modesty, that any of these might have something to teach him . . . Thus,” Santayana concluded, “William James became the friend and helper of those groping, nervous, half-educated, spiritually disinherited, passionately hungry individuals of which America is full.”27"

"William James: In the Maelstrom of American Modernism" by Robert D. Richardson: https://a.co/2DxCCsB

Wednesday, April 21, 2021

WJ & Karamazov

"James’s rejection of a plan (and a Planner) is like Ivan Karamazov’s. James declares it impossible to accept “a world in which Messrs Fourier’s and Bellamy’s and Morris’ utopias should all be outdone and millions kept permanently happy on the one simple condition that a certain lost soul on the far-off edge of things should lead a life of lonely torture.”"

"William James: In the Maelstrom of American Modernism" by Robert D. Richardson  https://a.co/bvWELwM

Saturday, April 17, 2021

WJ on Writers Almanac

It's the birthday (on Jan.11) of the psychologist and philosopher William James, (books by this author at the library) born in New York City (1842). He was the older brother of the novelist Henry James, and one of the most prominent thinkers of his era. He was a man who started out studying medicine and went on to become one of the founders of modern psychology, and finished his life as a prominent philosopher.

He was a professor of physiology at Harvard when he was hired to write a textbook about the new field of psychology, which was challenging the idea that the body and the mind were separate. He could have just written a summary of all the current ideas in the field but instead decided to explore the issues of psychology he found most interesting and perplexing. He took twelve years to finish the book called, The Principles of Psychology (1890). It was used as a textbook in college classrooms, but was also translated into a dozen different languages, and people read it all over the world.

One of the ideas he developed in the book was a theory of the human mind which he called "a stream of consciousness." Before him the common view was that a person's thoughts have a clear beginning and end, and that the thinker is in control of his or her thoughts. But William James wrote, "Consciousness … does not appear to itself chopped up in bits. Such words as 'chain' or 'train' do not describe it fitly as it presents itself in the first instance. It is nothing jointed; it flows."

James's ideas about consciousness were especially influential on writers, and novelists from James Joyce to William Faulkner began to portray streams of consciousness through language, letting characters think at length and at random on the page. Consciousness itself became one of the most important subjects of modern literature.

He also helped invent the technique of automatic writing, in which a person writes as quickly as possible whatever comes into one's head. He encouraged audiences to take up the practice as a form of self-analysis, and one person who took his advice was a student named Gertrude Stein, who went on to use it as the basis for her writing style.

William James wrote, "The stream of thought flows on; but most of its segments fall into the bottomless abyss of oblivion. Of some, no memory survives the instant of their passage. Of others, it is confined to a few moments, hours or days. Others, again, leave vestiges which are indestructible, and by means of which they may be recalled as long as life endures."

He also wrote, "Common sense and a sense of humor are the same thing, moving at different speeds. A sense of humor is just common sense, dancing." Writers Almanac

Slaves & freemen

In a letter WJ said that to be a philosopher you just have to find an idea to hate, but his more reflective judgment is in Talks to Teachers.

"In place of the mythological world of fixed ideas, James has given us a world of hammering energies, strong but evanescent feelings, activity of thought, and a profound and relentless focus on life now. For all his grand accomplishments in canonical fields of learning, James’s best is often in his unorthodox, half-blind, unpredictable lunges at the great question of how to live, and in this his work sits on the same shelf with Marcus Aurelius, Montaigne, Samuel Johnson, and Emerson. James’s best is urgent, direct, personal, and useful. Much of his writing came out of his teaching, and it has not yet lost the warmth of personal appeal, the sound of the man’s own voice. In one of his talks to teachers he said, “Spinoza long ago wrote in his Ethics that anything that a man can avoid under the notion that it is bad he may also avoid under the notion that something else is good. He who acts habitually sub specie mali, under the negative notion, the notion of the bad, is called a slave by Spinoza. To him who acts habitually under the notion of good he gives the name of freeman. See to it now, I beg you, that you make freemen of your pupils by habituating them to act, whenever possible, under the notion of a good.”21"

"William James: In the Maelstrom of American Modernism" by Robert D. Richardson: https://a.co/7PO434X

Richardson on WJ & $

There's actually quite a lot in Richardson's bio about WJ's money worries...

"During the first week of November 1898, James sent Henry Holt a letter and, the next day, the manuscript of Talks to Teachers. James was in a hurry. The Atlantic was going to publish many of the talks; Scribner’s Magazine would print at least one. James wanted to know at once what Holt planned to do. Holt replied to the letter before even seeing the manuscript: he would publish it. He offered James 10 percent of the list price until he recovered his costs, and 20 percent thereafter. James responded as many an author has yearned to do but has lacked the nerve. He proposed to publish the book himself (edit, design, print, and bind it), then let Holt advertise and distribute the book and take 10 percent of the list price for his pains. Publishers do not like this kind of talk. But Holt wanted the book. James’s royalties from Holt for 1898 for The Principles of Psychology and Psychology: Briefer Course came to $1,281.03. This was a substantial fraction of James’s income, and it meant that his work had been very profitable for Holt. Besides, Holt liked James, so he wrote back that James could have it his way, only he would have to understand that teachers got a 20 percent discount and dealers got another 20 percent. James would manufacture the book and would receive either 50 percent of the retail price (the book was to sell for a dollar) or 60 percent of the net (defined as the teachers’ price of 80 cents). This arrangement cost James a huge amount of work and correspondence, as he worried about paper, design, type, binding, production schedules, bills, delivery and pickup, and coordination with Holt, who gleefully hounded James with details. Holt obviously wanted to make the whole process as difficult as possible so that James’s cheekiness didn’t spread to other authors. But the book appeared in April 1899, and in January 1900 James got word that the Indiana Teachers’ Reading Circle had adopted it. This meant sales of between ten and fourteen thousand copies; James stood to make a minimum of $4,500 from this one adoption, and there were others to come. This was a great deal of money, more than the Giffords paid for a year and nearly the same as a year’s salary at Harvard. Talks to Teachers freed James of money worries. His feisty, provocative, and unconventional publishing gamble had paid off, even though it was a nuisance to bring off. James had learned something, and when the Varieties was ready for publication, he made a similar deal with Longmans, Green.6"

"William James: In the Maelstrom of American Modernism" by Robert D. Richardson: https://a.co/j4dgtGL

Wednesday, April 14, 2021

Talisse

Saturday, April 10, 2021

2 or 3

I think maybe a good history, to complement WJ. Gottlieb's Dreams (of Reason & Enlightenment), or (for a less western-parochial perspective) Baggini's How the World Thinks.
(https://twitter.com/OSOPHER/status/1380904132723290117?s=02)

2 books

If you could give only two books to a friend interested in understanding philosophy, what would they be? My choices: Nicomachean Ethics and the Writings of William James.
(https://twitter.com/EBCraigIV/status/1380206205461741571?s=02)

Pragmatism reading list, starter-suggestions

Definitely start with James's "Pragmatism"... Read his Letters, and Richardson's bio, to grasp its living context. Menand's " Metaphysical Club" situates WJ with Peirce and their young cohorts, and is also good on Dewey.
(https://twitter.com/OSOPHER/status/1380210660051714057?s=02)

"Spiritual"

Indeed! #CalvinandHobbes https://t.co/N9C46vQGTt
(https://twitter.com/Calvinn_Hobbes/status/1380868252084097036?s=02)

Who was talking about capital letters?

“Diversity is a good; it just isn’t the only one. When competence isn’t the first criterion for appointments, everybody loses—including thos...