Up@dawn 2.0

Sunday, February 21, 2021

John Lachs at the library

 A Lachs talk I'd not seen. Introduced by his former colleague (and fellow-former MTSU Applied Philosophy Lyceum speaker) David Wood as a "force of nature"...



Saturday, February 20, 2021

Thomas Davidson

A neglected philosopher of democracy and a teacher's teacher, appreciated by Doug Anderson in Philosophy Americana

"...philosophy’s central task is the education of individuals to a freer and more philosophically minded existence, such that they might create and maintain a better world. “The task of the centuries since the close of the Middle Ages has been,” he said, “gradually to remove this yoke of authority, and to raise men to freedom of thought, affection, and will—in a word, to rational self-guidance, or moral life.” Though not in a narrow way, philosophy is instrumental to the development of community. Again, Davidson saw this role of philosophy as standing in the tradition of the Greeks, as developing the love of wisdom in a social context. He was a Dewey-like believer in democracy’s possibilities and took “the task of the twentieth century” to be “to raise mankind, every member of it, to complete and actual moral freedom, which rests upon insight, just affection, and strong will, realizing themselves in a social order.” This task, as Dewey also believed, is at core an educational task. “A democracy cannot long be sustained,” Davidson argued, “by an ignorant demos...

The teacher who does not feel himself, or herself, an apostle with an important mission, but looks upon the teaching profession as a mere means of making a living, had better seek some other occupation. For Davidson this political transformation is appropriate to the development of a democracy and requires special attention on the part of the state so that education is public and extends “equally to all classes of the population” to ensure that there is “freedom from castes.” Providing the opportunity for learning and for leveling persons upward is a condition for successful democracy. As does Dewey, Davidson begins with the assumption that all persons can learn—that is, that they can, through the development of habits, create “harmonious worlds” for themselves. Since individual freedom depends on world building, and world building depends on learning, the primary task of any democracy must be to provide the possibility of learning for all its citizens. “The nation,” Davidson argued, speaking specifically of the United States in the twentieth century, “owes it to every one of its citizens to see to it that he has time and strength left to be a student.” It is therefore equally apparent that we philosophers and students of the humanities are central to the community’s work. Our task is to provide freedom and culture through teaching. Philosophy, history, and the arts, approached in Socratic fashion, enable lives that are “rich, full, and lofty.” As James noted, the Davidsonian teacher’s aim was not to create citizens who are “interchangeable parts” in a “rule-bound organism,” but to enable “flexible” lives through “liberation of the inner interests.” Despite its focus on individuals instead of institutions, Davidson’s take on the relationship of education to democracy is strongly reminiscent of features of Dewey’s Democracy and Education and, more specifically, of Dewey’s later essay “Creative Democracy: The Task Before Us.” Davidson simply focused on aspects of democracy and education that are less prominent, though present, in Dewey’s work. One such aspect was the individual’s responsibility to learn. Not only did the state have an obligation to make learning possible, but persons in a democracy have an obligation to be students. But they must be students as learning world builders, not as receptacles of information...


Through his actions, Davidson had made a case for the essentiality of teaching and given credence to his plea that the rest of us do more of it: If the teachers of the nation, with a due sense of their power and importance, would, without hope or desire for material reward, form themselves into an association for the higher education of the bread-winners … and each devote a couple of evenings a week to the work, they would soon elevate the culture of the whole people, and remove the worst dangers that threaten society... such an example seems difficult to follow so long as philosophy and teaching are understood primarily as professions confined to university campuses and not as life tasks essential to the development of democratic community. William James did not remind us of Thomas Davidson because of the latter’s scholarly work. Rather, he pointed us to the philosophy for which the act and art of teaching “cultural science” is central. Davidson was indeed a renegade; Dewey called him an “academic outlaw”—a title Davidson no doubt relished. His ideas are radical and suggestive. To be sure, we have established “continuing education” and “distance learning” programs in our high schools and colleges; but one gets the cynical sense that these programs are now oriented toward the production of degrees for students and the generation of money for schools. They fall well short of the Davidsonian ideal. When the majority of our high school students arrive at college with no conception of what we philosophers do or why we do it, it is important for us to take notice. Most of us teach, yet teaching is not, in general, a highly applauded practice in the contemporary academy. Many of us have not thought about how our teaching is related to our philosophical practices—not just our philosophical “positions.”

Philosophy Americana: Making Philosophy at Home in American Culture (American Philosophy Book 18) by Douglas R. Anderson: https://a.co/gUJcBrx

Friday, February 19, 2021

Thursday, February 18, 2021

Liberty Fund

 And speaking of conferences...

I participated in one of these Liberty Fund events once, in Indianapolis, at the invitation of the professor who moderated our discussions over several days. I didn't realize we "young" scholars -- I'm pretty sure I was over 40 at the time-- were being vetted for recruitment into the libertarian cause. Don't know if Buchanan was in attendance, I wouldn't have recognized him then, but I was never invited back. Must've been a "weak" prospect, possibly even a "misfit" and "bad apple"... I hope. ðŸ˜‰  

Anyway, I was pleased to drink their wine. (Actually I recall being more excited by the craft breweries in the vicinity.)

"Buchanan was hired by yet another Koch-backed organization, the Liberty Fund, to run what became annual summer conferences for the recruitment and training of young talent (defined as under age thirty-five, later upped to forty) in the social sciences. In essence, he was being asked to identify and begin preparing the intellectual cadre that Koch now believed was so critical to the cause’s success. Buchanan relished the role of gatekeeper. The evaluations he submitted for who had promise and who did not were highly detailed. One participant was “a highly articulate speaker, with basic instincts you and I share,” he reported, although “a bit ‘slick’” for “the country boys.” Another, despite a “poor expository style” and annoying “soft-left” reflexes, was still “interesting” and worth watching. The rankings were blunt: the judge divided the prospects into “Very Strong, Medium, [and] Weak.” At the best sessions, he could boast new “camaraderie” and “no misfits.” Like Koch, Buchanan was not squeamish about throwing flotsam overboard. Anyone unsound in doctrine or lacking in promise was unlikely to be invited back. He tried to “insure that no bad apples get into the barrel, for such can spoil the whole thing.” He required “explicit recommendation by those we trust for potential participants.” And he rewarded himself and his recruits in high style. The man who still called himself a country boy and railed against liberal “elitists” did not stint on frills, personally preselecting wines such as a 1966 Château Lafite-Rothschild that today would retail between $300 and $1,000 per bottle." 145-6

"Democracy in Chains: The Deep History of the Radical Right's Stealth Plan for America" by Nancy MacLean: https://a.co/iOUZFmb

==
Postscript. "I have run Liberty Fund programs and to the best of my knowledge nothing like this ever took place in them. It doesn’t surprise me that the Koch people want results for their money but if there are some talented “Left leaning” people in the group there should be some good conversations." John Lachs

Viva Las Vegas

I was at this conference (in 2000 or 2001), and had the same amused & bemused reaction as Doug:

"American scholars and philosophers are strange and culturally estranged. One need only attend a few philosophy conferences to experience this. But I don’t intend this claim pejoratively—our minds run in different grooves and highways, and that is a good thing. My most memorable picture of this estrangement came when a group of American philosophers, in full tweed, met for a conference in the Tropicana Hotel in Las Vegas. The juxtaposition of slot machines and craps tables with staid discussions of Dewey’s virtue ethics was, in an odd and striking way, a kind of American beauty in itself, at once funny and deadly serious." Philosophy Americana: Making Philosophy at Home in American Culture (American Philosophy Book 18)" by Douglas R. Anderson: https://a.co/gKvNUa8

Monday, February 15, 2021

A Moment of Reckoning

 Originally posted at Democracy in America...

Up at dawn, I had a jumble of thoughts inspired by the impeachment and my inability to understand the appeal of Drumpf to 74 million voters. 81 million chose Joe. What is it that divides the 74 from the 81?

I am a product of a Republican family. I know plenty of Republicans. I don’t think that any of them five years ago would countenance the kind of behavior that Drumpf has engaged in since his election as president. Yet today they do; at least they tolerate and accept it. I first thought, why have they changed? But then I thought, perhaps they haven’t changed at all. Perhaps the great divide between the 74 and the 81 reveals a fundamental, maybe evolutionally developed, difference in nature; a difference in American character.

For many in the 81, Donald Drumpf is a fatally flawed human being, with his garish lifestyle, with his gilded palaces, his obvious lack of virtue, and his buffoonery. We know his character by his acts, and it isn't pretty.

Why don’t the 74 see this? I hypothesize that they do see it, but they see something in him they value. They see in him a fulfillment of the American dream. Gold toilets in a Manhattan high-rise, Mar-a-Lago, private jets, beautiful women, etc. And they believe that all this material success is the result of rugged American individualism that characterizes Americanism. This is the character of those that conquered a continent, built railroads and steel mills, and made America great. Howard Roark.

Donald Drumpf is a radical narcissist. He cares about one thing – himself. He embodies a concept of individualism that many Americans see as the essence of the American character. His character, seen through the prism of this perspective of individualism, may be a bit flawed, but he represents American values that the 74, by their nature, possess.

The 81 have a different perspective on individualism. Theirs includes caring for others. They are more likely than the 74 to look through their prism and see problems that affect others in society and to seek solutions that involve change. The 74 resist change, and see authoritarian preservation of the status quo as necessary to maintain American democracy.

The actions of the January 6th mob are indefensible. Their ‘means’ are simply not acceptable in a democracy. But, what about their ‘ends’? Over and over, before, after, and during, their loudest spokespeople proclaimed their mission was and is to preserve American democracy. Was that not the concern of the 81 in the 2020 election? We all have a common goal. We cannot make any progress toward reconciliation without addressing this point.

There is a historical aspect to our present problem. You cannot separate out of the American experience our experience with race. We brought human beings to this country as slaves. We fought a horrible bloody civil war over the right to own and enslave human beings. The descendants of slaves comprise much of our population. These descendants have suffered injustice for 400 years, which continues to this day. And the mob that invaded the capitol carried Confederate battle flags.

Our country is now in a cold civil war. White supremacism has been revealed in all aspects of our society. We face the challenge of white supremacist militias like the Proud Boys, and threats of domestic terrorism (terrorism being violent actions to achieve a political goal).

Today’s civil war is a moral war. It is a war over the proper ethic for Americanism. It is, as Joe said, a war for the soul of the nation. Is Americanism to be characterized by ruthless materialistic individualism, or by empathy for others, and the seeking of a just society? This is a moment of reckoning.

In order to properly address this moment, we must try to understand each other, and reconcile the apparent paradox that both sides have the same goal. We will not rise to the occasion if we only tell the other side why they are objectively wrong. We must try to understand – and appreciate - their subjective feelings. We need to stand in each other's shoes, and articulate each other’s positions. Only then will we be able to reconcile our different means to our common goal. 

--Ed Craig

(aka "Grandfather Philosophy")


4 comments:

  1. Thanks for this, Ed.

    As we've discussed, grasping another's subjectivity can be extraordinarily hard. But grasping that others have interior lives as rich and compelling to them as ours are to us shouldn't be so hard.

    Some others are far less reflective, of course, and less open to this kind of mutual and reciprocal receptivity. I don't imagine we'd make much headway in an exchange of subjectivities with the guy in horns and fur(for instance) and his January 6 comrades. But I appreciate, and William James would appreciate, your willingness to call out "a certain blindness in human beings"...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. OUR judgments concerning the worth of things, big or little, depend on the feelings the things arouse in us. Where we judge a thing to be precious in consequence of the idea we frame of it, this is only because the idea is itself associated already with a feeling. If we were radically feelingless, and if ideas were the only things our mind could entertain, we should lose all our likes and dislikes at a stroke, and be unable to point to any one situation or experience in life more valuable or significant than any other.

      Now the blindness in human beings, of which this discourse will treat, is the blindness with which we all are afflicted in regard to the feelings of creatures and people different from ourselves.

      We are practical beings, each of us with limited functions and duties to perform. Each is bound to feel intensely the importance of his own duties and the significance of the situations that call these forth. But this feeling is in each of us a vital secret, for sympathy with which we vainly look to others. The others are too much absorbed in their own vital secrets to take an interest in ours. Hence the stupidity and injustice of our opinions, so far as they deal with the significance of alien lives. Hence the falsity of our judgments, so far as they presume to decide in an absolute way on the value of other persons' conditions or ideals.

      Take our dogs and ourselves... (continues)
      https://www.uky.edu/~eushe2/Pajares/jcertain.html
      ==
      William James
      https://www.uky.edu/~eushe2/Pajares/james.html#significant

      Delete
  2. I think he also expressed a similar sentiment in The Moral Equivalent of War.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "...If now -- and this is my idea -- there were, instead of military conscription, a conscription of the whole youthful population to form for a certain number of years a part of the army enlisted against Nature, the injustice would tend to be evened out, and numerous other goods to the commonwealth would remain blind as the luxurious classes now are blind, to man's relations to the globe he lives on, and to the permanently sour and hard foundations of his higher life. To coal and iron mines, to freight trains, to fishing fleets in December, to dishwashing, clotheswashing, and windowwashing, to road-building and tunnel-making, to foundries and stoke-holes, and to the frames of skyscrapers, would our gilded youths be drafted off, according to their choice, to get the childishness knocked out of them, and to come back into society with healthier sympathies and soberer ideas. They would have paid their blood-tax, done their own part in the immemorial human warfare against nature; they would tread the earth more proudly, the women would value them more highly, they would be better fathers and teachers of the following generation..."

      https://www.uky.edu/~eushe2/Pajares/moral.html

Sunday, February 14, 2021

Special Issue of William James Studies: James and Peirce (English, Spanish, or Portuguese)

When reading the following announcement, one might keep in mind the image of hatted, baggy-pants William James decked out on his trip to Brazil.


--Tadd Ruetenik

Secretary, William James Society


---


SPECIAL ISSUE OF WILLIAM JAMES STUDIES: 

JAMES AND PEIRCE


The WILLIAM JAMES SOCIETY is pleased to invite essays for an upcoming Special Issue of William James Studies. This Special Issue, guest edited by Daniel Herbert and Paniel Reyes Cardenas, will explore new connections between the works of William James and CS Peirce. In a first for William James Studies, essays may be submitted in English, Spanish, or Portuguese. Papers will be accepted until 30 June 2021.


WILLIAM JAMES SOCIETY solicita ensayos para una próxima edición de William James Studies. Este volumen especial, editado por Daniel Herbert y Paniel Reyes Cardenas, explorará nuevas conexiones entre las obras de William James y las de C. S. Peirce. Por primera vez en William James Studies, ensayos podrían ser sometidos en Inglés, Español, o Portugues. Se aceptarán ensayos hacia 30 June 2021.  

 

Please see the Call for Papers for full details and instructions. Questions may be directed to our Guest Editors Daniel Herbert (d.r.herbert@sheffield.ac.uk) and Paniel Reyes Cardenas (panielosberto.reyes@upaep.mx).

The Call for Papers may be viewed on the William James Studies website (https://williamjamesstudies.org/call-for-papers/).

Kyle Bromhall, PhD

Managing Editor, 
William James Studies.

--
Tadd Ruetenik
Professor of Philosophy 
St. Ambrose University

Saturday, February 13, 2021

Pure Experience, Radical Empiricism

A World of Pure Experience
William James (1904)

First published in Journal of Philosophy, Psychology, and Scientific Methods, 1, 533-543, 561-570.

It is difficult not to notice a curious unrest in the philosophic atmosphere of the time, always loosening of old landmarks, a softening of oppositions, a mutual borrowing from one another reflecting on the part of systems anciently closed, and an interest in new suggestions, however vague, as if the one thing sure were the inadequacy of the extant school-solutions. The dissatisfaction with these seems due for the most part to a feeling that they are too abstract and academic. Life is confused and superabundant, and what the younger generation appears to crave is more of the temperament of life in its philosophy, even though it were at some cost of logical rigor and of formal purity. Transcendental idealism is inclining to let the world wag incomprehensibly, in spite of its Absolute Subject and his unity of purpose. Berkeleyan idealism is abandoning the principle of parsimony and dabbling in panpsychic speculations. Empiricism flirts with teleology; and, strangest of all, natural realism, so long decently buried, raises its head above the turf, and finds glad hands outstretched from the most unlikely quarters to help it to its feet again. We are all biased by our personal feelings, I know, and I am personally discontented with extant solutions; so I seem to read the signs of a great unsettlement, as if the upheaval of more real conceptions and more fruitful methods were imminent, as if a true landscape might result, less clipped, straight-edged and artificial.

If philosophy be really on the eve of any considerable rearrangement, the time should be propitious for any one who has suggestions of his own to bring forward. For many years past my mind has been growing into a certain type of Weltanschauung. Rightly or wrongly, I have got to the point where I can hardly see things in any other pattern. I propose, therefore, to describe the pattern as clearly as I can consistently with great brevity, and to throw my description into the bubbling vat of publicity where, jostled by rivals and torn by critics, it will eventually either disappear from notice, or else, if better luck befall it, quietly subside to the profundities, and serve as a possible ferment of new growths or a nucleus of new crystallization... (continues)

The Varieties of Pure Experience: William James and Kitaro Nishida on Consciousness and Embodiment

Joel W. Krueger

1. Introduction 
The notion of “pure experience” is one of the most intriguing and simultaneously perplexing features of William James’s writings. There seems to be little consensus in the secondary literature as to how to understand this notion, and precisely what function it serves within the overall structure of James’s thought. Yet James himself regards this idea as the cornerstone of his radical empiricism. And the latter, James felt, was his unique contribution to the history of philosophy; he believed that philosophy “was on the eve of a considerable rearrangement” when his essay “A World of Pure Experience” was first published in 1904. While Western philosophy is still perhaps awaiting this “considerable rearrangement,” James’s notion of pure experience was quickly appropriated by another thinker who in fact did inaugurate a considerable rearrangement of his own intellectual tradition: the Japanese philosopher Kitaro Nishida (1870—1945), the founder and most important figure of the Kyoto School of modern Japanese philosophy.
1
Kitaro Nishida is widely recognized as Japan’s foremost modern philosopher. His earliest major work, An Inquiry into the Good (1911), is generally considered to be the founding statement of the Kyoto School of modern Japanese philosophy. Other prominent Kyoto School figures, including Hajime Tanabe (1885–1962), Keiji Nishitani (1900–1990), and Masao Abe (1915– ), each acknowledged the profound influence of Nishida’s work on their own intellectual development. Pluralistic in his outlook and comparative in his methodology, Nishida was throughout his life deeply influenced by a number of western thinkers and religious figures (a trait shared by most other prominent Kyoto School figures). For instance, Nishida speaks favorably of Augustine, Kant, Hegel and Bergson, and concedes that these Western thinkers, among others, had a hand in shaping his thought.
2
But it was with James’s formulation of pure experience that Nishida first believed that he had found a conceptual apparatus upon which he could ground the characteristic themes and concerns that have since been designated “Nishida Philosophy.” Additionally, Nishida felt that James’s idea of pure experience was able to preserve some of the more important features of Buddhist thought that Nishida looked to incorporate into his own system... (continues)

==

RECONSTRUCTING JAMES’S EARLY RADICAL EMPIRICISM: THE 1896 PREFACE AND “THE SPIRIT OF INNER TOLERANCE”

ERMINE L. ALGAIER IV

ABSTRACT. This paper re-contextualizes William James’s early radical empiricism based upon a historical and philosophical reading of the 1896 preface of The Will to Believe. I suggest that James’s “irrational” early radical empiricism, as guided by the “spirit of inner tolerance,” is tinged with a fringe sensitivity or awareness of the epistemic outsider. Based upon his critique of the blind monist, this paper argues that when we look toward a wider conception of James’s philosophy, it reveals that his early radical empiricism is intimately concerned with social and moral elements with regard to matters of fact and perspective. Utilizing Gavin’s manifest-latent hermeneutic, I show how James defends this type of outsider, the epistemic underdog, with the hope of creating a more open, free, and democratic marketplace of ideas and practices that is predicated upon the value of respectful difference.

When we look toward James’s first public announcement of radical empiricism, it becomes clear that we need to be more critical as to how we discuss his ideas. In contrast to Edward Madden’s interpretation, I am suggesting that we avoid using James’s later formulation (e.g. his 1904-05 technical writings) as a measuring stick for his 1896 articulation.[1] As we inquire into James’s early radical empiricism,[2] we ought to not assume that he is directly concerned with metaphysics, with pure experience, and the epistemological relations of the subject-object dichotomy.[3] A more critical reading, I suggest, is one which draws from the historical, thematic, and philosophical context of James’s work in the mid to late 1890’s... (continues)



On a Certain Blindness in Human Beings

OUR judgments concerning the worth of things, big or little, depend on the feelings the things arouse in us. Where we judge a thing to be precious in consequence of the idea we frame of it, this is only because the idea is itself associated already with a feeling. If we were radically feelingless, and if ideas were the only things our mind could entertain, we should lose all our likes and dislikes at a stroke, and be unable to point to any one situation or experience in life more valuable or significant than any other.

Now the blindness in human beings, of which this discourse will treat, is the blindness with which we all are afflicted in regard to the feelings of creatures and people different from ourselves.

We are practical beings, each of us with limited functions and duties to perform. Each is bound to feel intensely the importance of his own duties and the significance of the situations that call these forth. But this feeling is in each of us a vital secret, for sympathy with which we vainly look to others. The others are too much absorbed in their own vital secrets to take an interest in ours. Hence the stupidity and injustice of our opinions, so far as they deal with the significance of alien lives. Hence the falsity of our judgments, so far as they presume to decide in an absolute way on the value of other persons' conditions or ideals.

Take our dogs and ourselves... (continues)
==

Friday, February 12, 2021

Philosophy Americana

 A more hirsute Doug Anderson -- no bald-headed erkentnisstheorist he -- on real philosophy.

 

PHILOSOPHY AMERICANA

MAKING PHILOSOPHY AT HOME IN AMERICAN CULTURE

By Douglas R. Anderson

In this engaging book, Douglas Anderson begins with the assumption that philosophy—the Greek love of wisdom—is alive and well in American culture. At the same time, professional philosophy remains relatively invisible.

Anderson traverses American life to find places in the wider culture where professional philosophy in the distinctively American tradition can strike up a conversation. How might American philosophers talk to us about our religious experience, or political engagement, or literature—or even, popular music?

Anderson’s second aim is to find places where philosophy happens in nonprofessional guises—cultural places such as country music, rock’n roll, and Beat literature. He not only enlarges the tradition of American philosophers such as John Dewey and William James by examining lesser-known figures such as Henry Bugbee and Thomas Davidson, but finds the theme and ideas of American philosophy in some unexpected places, such as the music of Hank Williams, Tammy Wynette, and Bruce Springsteen, and the writings of Jack Kerouac.

The idea of “philosophy Americana” trades on the emergent genre of “music Americana,” rooted in traditional themes and styles yet engaging our present experiences. The music is “popular” but not thoroughly driven by economic considerations, and Anderson seeks out an analogous role for philosophical practice, where philosophy and popular culture are co-adventurers in the life of ideas. Philosophy Americana takes seriously Emerson’s quest for the extraordinary in the ordinary and James’s belief that popular philosophy can still be philosophy.






Who was talking about capital letters?

“Diversity is a good; it just isn’t the only one. When competence isn’t the first criterion for appointments, everybody loses—including thos...