Supporting the study, critique, and appreciation of American philosophy and culture--"American Studies"-- in the tradition of William James, John Dewey, Charles Sanders Peirce, Emerson, Thoreau, et al... This site was constructed initially to support an Independent Readings course at Middle Tennessee State University in the Spring 2021 semester.
Monday, August 25, 2025
The experience of perspective
Sunday, August 24, 2025
"Doing and creating and suffering"
A slightly different take on WJ's youthful commitment to free will-
"Set in the biographical context of James’s back pain and mental ill health, it would seem that free will, as a philosophy of indeterminism, represented, for him, the chance that his own situation might improve. It was the intellectual foundation on which hope and resilience were made possible; the hope that eventually, perhaps, his future and others’ would be less blighted with the evils of illness and pain.116
A diary entry for April 30, 1870, recorded James’s adoption of this new perspective and how he applied it to his own life. He wrote of how, “hitherto, when I have felt like taking a free initiative, like daring to act originally, . . . suicide seemed the only most manly form to put my daring into.” He then proposed a new way of thinking about his future, however, one that was predicated on a belief in the reality of his own “free will” and “creative power,” a life built on “doing and creating and suffering.”117"
"William James, MD: Philosopher, Psychologist, Physician" by Emma K. Sutton: https://a.co/hWf2zf8
Friday, August 22, 2025
"William James, MD: Philosopher, Psychologist, Physician"
"James was awarded his MD from Harvard Medical School in March 1869, after more than five years of interrupted study. This certificate lists his examiners, who included Oliver Wendel Holmes Sr., and the subject of his thesis, namely, the effects of cold on the body. (Diplomas, degrees, notifications of appointments, etc., William James papers [MS Am 1092.9–1092.12, MS Am 1092.9 (4571), Box: 40], Houghton Library, Harvard University.)
There is one element of James’s life and work that unites these disparate identities, however. In 1869, several years before he secured his first lectureship, he graduated from Harvard Medical School and earned his MD. Hampered by his own ill health, James abandoned his plans to practice as a doctor, but these studies were only the beginning of a profound and lifelong occupation with questions about the essential nature of health, healing, and invalidism and their implications for society. His writings, across their disciplinary breadth, return time after time to issues of a medical provenance. In this book I make the case that James’s medical interests, concerns, and values are the threads that bind many of his seemingly unconnected pursuits together. They are the warp and weft of many of his best-known publications and major lines of thought."
...
"William James, MD: Philosopher, Psychologist, Physician" by Emma K. Sutton: https://a.co/4PTkAZq
Saturday, August 16, 2025
William James and I went to a Cubs game at Wrigley Field
It was a nice dream. We didn't care if we ever got back.
"When my revered friend and teacher William James wrote an essay on “A Moral Equivalent for War,” I suggested to him that baseball already embodied all the moral value of war, so far as war had any moral value. He listened sympathetically and was amused, but he did not take me seriously enough. All great men have their limitations, and William James’s were due to the fact that he lived in Cambridge, a city which, in spite of the fact that it has a population of 100,000 souls (including the professors), is not represented in any baseball league that can be detected without a microscope..." Morris R. Cohen, in The Dial,Vol. 67, p. 57 (July 26, 1919)In the beginning (of the William James Society): "The Streams of William James"
William James Society executive board member and (with his Pragmatism Cybrary) master archivist of American Philosophy John Shook informed us at yesterday's board meeting that he has recovered the earliest society publications, going back to "The Streams of William James" which launched, with the Society itself, back in 1999. And here they are... including my own contributions to the first issue (which I remembered, vaguely) and the third (which I'd entirely forgotten), here:
Thanks for the memories, John. And the institutional memory.
Monday, August 11, 2025
Stoic Pragmatism 6: Open Seminars Online (Chris Skowronski)
Stoic Pragmatism: Open Seminars Online
SEMINAR SIX: Why Has Cultural Pluralism (so often) Been a Challenge? Wednesday, August 13, 2025, 19.00-20.30, Berlin Time (CEST)
Zoom link HERE:
https://us06web.zoom.us/j/88293106089?pwd=Uaef7fHbPCAPLu0XkgdcJ9SQUuIYMA.1
Programme of Seminar Two:
I Chris Skowronski’s talk
II Open discussion about the talk
III Questions and Comments about other topics, if there are any
Questions and Issues to be discussed
1 When did the term “cultural pluralism” (as philosophical stance) appear in pragmatism and what did it refer to? And how is it difference with a colloquial meaning of this term?
2 Can we talk about cultural pluralism in the context of stoic pragmatism?
3 Why cultural pluralism (in a colloquial meaning) is so challenging?
4 Any links with the Cynic/Stoic idea of cosmopolitanism?
5 What is the difference between cultural pluralism (philosophical stance) and such cultural policies as multiculturalism, the Melting Pot, globalization, DEI/EDI, and similar policies?
A short presentation of some published claims or stances related to these questions and issues (see full bibliography below).
Definition of and conditions for cultural pluralism by German-American pragmatist, Horace Kallen:
A “Standpoint” saying that culture means a positive and “sympathetic recognition and understanding of differences” (Kallen 1998 [1924], 56).
“Cultural growth is founded upon Cultural Pluralism. Cultural Pluralism is possible only in a democratic society whose institutions encourage individuality in groups, in persons, in temperaments, whose program liberates these individualities and guides them into a fellowship of freedom and cooperation“ (Kallen 1998 [1924], 43).
Kallen’s teacher at Harvard, Santayana’s related stance:
“Human virtues and human forms of society had various natural models, according to differences of nature or of circumstances. Virtue, like health, has different shades according to race, sex, age, and personal endowment. In each phase of life and art a different perfection may be approached” (Santayana 1995 [1951], 337).
Stoic cosmopolitanism (Marcus Aurelius)
“If thought is something we share, then so is reason—what makes us reasoning beings. If so, then the reason that tells us what to do and what not to do is also shared. And if so, we share a common law. And thus, are fellow citizens. And fellow citizens of something. And in that case, our state must be the world. What other entity could all of humanity belong to? And from it—from this state that we share—come thought and reason and law“ (Marcus Aurelius, Meditations IV, 4)
Stoic (Hierocles) metaphor of concentric circles (widening circles of concern, oikeiosis) “The first and closest circle is that which each person draws around his own mind, as the center: in this circle is enclosed the body and whatever is employed for the sake of the body. For this circle is the shortest and all but touches its own center. The second after this one, standing further away from the center and enclosing the first, is that within which our parents, siblings, wife, and children are
ranged. Third, after these, is that in which there are uncles and aunts, grandfathers and grandmothers, the children of one’s siblings, and also cousins. After this comes the one that embraces all other relatives. next upon this is the circle of the members of one’s deme, then that of the members of one’s tribe, next that of one’s fellow citizens, and so, finally, that of those who border one’s city and that of people of like ethnicity. The furthest out and largest one, which surrounds all the circles, is that of the entire race of human beings” (Hierocles 91)
Stoic pragmatist stance (Lachs/Skowroński on cosmopolitanism and widening circles of concern)
“The idea of oikeíôsis (most famously pronounced by Hierocles) says that my interests and social engagement should move outwards, from my individual self to my family, then, if possible, to my fellow citizens, and then finally to my fellow human beings. The metaphor of a stone thrown into the water and creating waves, smaller and smaller, yet spiraling out to the farther regions of the pond, illustrates the direction my energy should go out into public, social, and cultural life. Lachs makes this picture more social, pragmatist, normative, and even sees this ‘expansion of ego-boundaries” as “an aim of civilization’(Lachs 1998, 35)” (Skowroński 2023, 20)
Stoic pragmatist stance (Lachs on cosmopolitanism and widening circles of concern) We should “distinguish our obligations to those near and dear from duties to unknown multitudes around the globe. If I owe everything I can provide to everyone who can use it, I must not prefer meeting my children’s needs to feeding the hungry in East Timor” (Lachs 2012, 105).
“The history of civilization coincides precisely with the gradual expansion of the boundaries of the self. We have learned to see first others close to us, then anonymous members of our group, eventually our enemies, and finally, in a halting way, the multitude of strangers that constitute humankind as somehow vitally involved in who we are. Only such extended ego-boundaries can explain why industrial nations offer helping hands when disaster strikes on the other side of the globe. We can see self-interest as the source of foreign aid, of peacekeeping missions, and of humanitarian help only if we think in terms of such an enlarged notion of self” (Lachs 1998, 33-34).
Santayana’s stance on cosmopolitanism and widening circles of concern
“A psychological sense in which an individual may transcend himself. His thoughts will embrace all his familiar surroundings; and his habits being necessarily social, his passions will be social too. The scope of his affections may eventually extend over the whole world” (Santayana 1969, 196).
“The full grown human soul should respect all traditions and understand all passions;; at the same time it should possess and embody a particular culture, without unmanly relaxation or mystical neutrality” (Santayana 1986 [1944-1953], 464).
Related stance by M. Nussbaum: cosmopolitanism / concentric circles
“I argue that Cicero provides a promising way forward, which we can further develop. Just as we can defend the intrinsic and motivational importance of ties to family and friends without denying that we owe something to all our fellow citizens (which a just tax system would presumably arrange), it is possible to cultivate (through moral and civic education) a type of patriotism that is, on the one hand, compatible with strong familial, friendly, and personal love, and, on the other hand, builds ties of recognition and concern with people outside our national borders. This has often been done, and great Political leaders including Lincoln, Nehru, F.D.R., and Martin Luther King, Jr. have succeeded, at least for periods of time, in cultivating that type of mixed concern in their nations” (Nussbaum 2019, 13).
“In practical terms, we may give what is near to us a special degree of attention and concern. But we should always remember that these features of placement are incidental and that our most fundamental allegiance is to what is human. Special duties are just delegations from the general duty to humanity. The special measure of concern we give to our own is justified not by any intrinsic value of the local, but by the overall requirements of humanity. (The Stoics think that we usually promote the goals of humanity best by doing our duty where life has placed us—raising our own children, for example, rather than trying vainly to care for all the world’s children)” (Nussbaum 2019, 78).
Bibliography
Hierocles 2009. Hierocles, the Stoic: Elements of Ethics, Fragments and Excerpts. Translation David Konstan. Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature.
Kallen, Horace 1998 (1924). Culture and Democracy in the United States. New Brunswick and London: Transactions Publishers.
Lachs, John and Shirley Lachs, eds. 1969. Physical Order and Moral Liberty: Previously Unpublished Essays of George Santayana. Nashville: Vanderbilt University Press.
Lachs, John. 1998. In Love with Life: Reflections on the joy of living and why we hate to die. Nashville: Vanderbilt University Press.
Lachs, John. 2012. Stoic Pragmatism. Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press. Marcus Aurelius. Meditations. Translation Gregory Hays. New York; The Modern Library. Nussbaum, Martha 2019. The Cosmopolitan Tradition: A Noble but Flawed Ideal. Harvard University Press. Santayana, George 1986 (1944–1953). Persons and Places: Fragments of Autobiography. Cambridge, Mass.: The MIT Press.
Santayana, George 1995 (1951). Dominations and Powers: Reflections on Liberty, Society, and Government. New Brunswick and London: Transaction Publishers.
Santayana 1969; see Lachs 1969.
Skowroński, Krzysztof P. 2023. A Meaningful Life amidst a Pluralism of Cultures and Values: John Lachs’s Stoic Pragmatism as a Philosophical and Cultural Project. Leiden-Boston: Brill. See also: stoic pragmatism bibliography http://berlinphilosophyforum.org/stoic-pragmatism-bibliography updated-may-2024/
See more about stoic pragmatism here: http://berlinphilosophyforum.org/stoic-pragmatism/Friday, August 1, 2025
The general’s greatest conquest
he was done.
Equally impressive was his winning battle against alcohol. Twain understood:
"Mark Twain had struggled with similar cravings for alcohol and tobacco. When they discussed the subject, Grant mentioned that although doctors had urged him to sip whiskey or champagne, he could no longer abide the taste of liquor. Twain pondered this statement long and hard. "Had he made a conquest so complete that even the taste of liquor was become an offense?" he wondered. "Or was he so sore over what had been said about his habit that he wanted to persuade others & likewise himself that he hadn't ever even had any taste for it." 95 Similarly, when Grant told Twain that, at the doctors' behest, he had been restricted to one cigar daily, he claimed to have lost the desire to smoke it. "I could understand that feeling," Twain later proclaimed. "He had set out to conquer not the habit but the inclination—the desire. He had gone at the root, not the trunk." 96 Although Twain hated puritanical killjoys who robbed life of its small pleasurable vices, he respected abstinence based on an absence of desire."
— Grant by Ron Chernow
https://a.co/1C1oYrI
Wednesday, July 30, 2025
Tuesday, July 29, 2025
William James Society: summer '25 newsletter
Summer 2025 Newsletter
President’s Message from Dr. Phil Oliver
When I think of William James in summer, I think naturally of his annual escape at term’s end to his Chocorua summer home in New Hampshire, with (he told his sister Alice) its “fourteen doors, all opening out”…

I think as well of his many Adirondack excursions, where at the end of one day’s hike he came upon a “ferocious metaphysical dispute” surrounding a squirrel…

and where he had what he called a Walpurgis Nacht pseudo-mystical experience…
And then I think of the terrific split-venue Chocorua/Cambridge centenary celebration of his life and work the James Society sponsored in August 2010, “in the footsteps of William James,” coinciding with Harvard’s Houghton Library exhibition Life is in the Transitions.
I think of the time he got horribly lost on a hike and probably propelled the heart-strain that expedited his exit from this earth at age 68 in August 1910.
And of course I think of the nobility of that exit. It was in his dying summer a hundred and fifteen year ago, when he penned a marvelous riposte to Henry Adams’s morose pessimism over the universe’s own mortality. The entire letter (dated June 17, 1910) is a tour de force of indomitably life-affirming human spirit, even in the shadow of looming personal extinction. It concludes with a crescendo of defiantly insistent hopefulness: “Though the ultimate state of the universe may be its vital and psychical extinction, there is nothing in physics to interfere with the hypothesis that the penultimate state might be… a maximum of happy and virtuous consciousness would be the only result. In short, the last expiring pulsation of the universe’s life might be, ‘I am so happy and perfect that I can stand it no longer.'”
Isn’t that an exit!
It was in his terminal summer that James declared, a bit disingenuously, that there were “no fortunes to be told and no advice to be given,” in the conclusion of his final publication, “A Pluralistic Mystic”-a paean to his eccentric friend Benjamin Blood, but from our vantage more a brave “Farewell!” at the conclusion of a remarkably inspiring, perceptive, and humane life devoted to the unyielding defense of experience in all its irreducible variety.
The disingenuity in question has less to do with fortune-telling (though he was more than sufficiently receptive to the experience of unscrupulous seers and non-creditable prognosticators) than with advice. He was full of that. “Be not afraid of life” was one of his better lines, in this regard.
And it’s probably the line we need most to heed ourselves, in this summer of our own (and America’s) unsettled fortune. He’d tell us, I’m sure: you can stand it.
As he told us just before that final farewell: “There is no conclusion. What has concluded, that we might conclude in regard to it?”
We’re still here, to enjoy experience and to shape it; to enjoy the world and to change it.
So say we at the William James Society, in the spirit of our namesake: enjoy your summer, and ameliorate your world.
Phil Oliver, President, William James Society
Digital Spotlight
“Revisiting the Classics with AI” – John Kaag (May 13, 2025)
WJS Vice President John Kaag considers what it means to engage James in an era increasingly shaped by artificial intelligence. He explores how digital tools might extend James’s commitment to pluralism and the varieties of experience.
This short piece is ideal for faculty and students interested in public philosophy and digital pedagogy.
Access the Rebind AI E-book of Varieties of Religious Experience with John Kaag and Bessel Van Kolk
Community Updates
- WJS Member Wayne Viney recently published “James on Unification” in History of Psychology 27, No. 4, (2024) 371-383 https://doi.org/10.1037/hop0000265
- Past WJS President Sami Pihlström published Humanism, Antitheodicism, and the Critique of Meaning in Pragmatist Philosophy of Religion (Lexington, 2023), containing two chapters focusing on James. James figures prominently in Pihlström’s edited volume, The Bloomsbury Handbook of Pragmatism (Bloomsbury, 2024).
- 2025 SAAP Recap: The March meeting in Washington, D.C. featured strong Jamesian representation. Look for reflections and photos in William James Studies.
- WJS Member Highlights: New fellowships, recent publications, upcoming events? Let us know! Submissions for the Fall newsletter due by October 15, 2025.
- Membership Reminder: Renew for the 2025–2026 academic year. Encourage colleagues and graduate students to join—especially those working in psychology, religious studies, education, and political theory. Our pluralism is stronger with broader participation.
Recent Publications on William James
The Spring 2025 issue of William James Studies (Vol. 20, No. 1)
Published in June, this issue features:
Proceedings from SAAP Boston 2024
Original research articles including:
“Depression and Pragmatism”
“Environments of Madness in James and Dewey”
Book reviews of Philip Davis’s Pathways in William James
and Clifford Stagoll’s Pragmatist Imagination
A curated list of James-relevant works published in other venues over the past academic year
🔗 Read the full issue here
Recent Publications in Focus
Bernadette Baker, William James, Sciences of Mind, and Anti-Imperial Discourse (Cambridge University Press, 2025)
This provocative and rigorously researched volume places James’s psychology and pluralism in dialogue with the cultural and political legacies of American empire. A timely resource for scholars interested in James’s transnational relevance and the politics of epistemology.
🔗 Publisher’s page
J. Edward Hackett, William James’ Radically Empirical Philosophy of Religion (Springer, 2025)
This book takes a stand against and critiques readings of William James that do not pay attention to the metaphysics of experience. Such interpretations overlook the first mentions of radical empiricism in James’s Will to Believe argument. By attending to James’s metaphysics of experience, this book argues that James’s universe is a “quasi-chaos” of becoming in our relations with nature and other people, so that things independent of us relate, evolve, and change in space and time. James’s metaphysics of relations is what unifies his various psychological, poetic, mystical, and religious commitments. These metaphysical implications have consequences for how James understood what metaphysics can do in philosophy, how it relates to theology, what we can say about his will-to-believe argument, mysticism, free-will, God’s finitism, the problem of One and the Many, and panpsychism.
🔗 Publisher’s page
Essay: “Censoring William James” (May 2025, Forbidden Histories)
This accessible piece explores how James’s psychical research—long marginalized in mainstream academic discourse—is now being re-evaluated in light of broader concerns about the boundaries of science, credibility, and intellectual openness.
By revisiting James’s willingness to engage what others dismissed, it subtly affirms his melioristic and democratic spirit.
🔗 Read here
More recent publications on William James
Compiled by WJS At-large member John Shook
An evaluation of philosophically driven palliative care research using the pragmatist philosophy of William James A Pettifer, P Guo – Palliative Medicine, 2025
Bridging the theory-practice divide in public administration: A virtuous pragmatic approach of Wang Yangming and William James Y Ni, N Liu – Public Policy and Administration, 2025 – journals.sagepub.com
Mysticisme et pragmatisme dans la philosophie religieuse d’Alfred Loisy: une comparaison avec William James A Lannoy – Revue de Theologie et de Philosophi, 2025
The Issue of the Pragmatist Sources of Post-Truth, Considered in the Light of William James‘ Definition of Truth M Wójtowicz – Forum Philosophicum, 2025 – pdcnet.org
William James and Scientific Medicine. A Portrait of the Critic Within P Croce – European Journal of Pragmatism and American Philosophy, 2025
William James M Sehgal – Whitehead-Handbuch: Leben–Werk–Wirkung, 2025 – Springer
William James‘ Debt to Hermann Lotze M Vagnetti – Geltung, revista de estudos das origens da filosofia …, 2025 – revistas.pucsp.br
William James, David Bohm, and the Puzzle of Consciousness W Seager – Journal of Consciousness Studies, 2025 – ingentaconnect.com
REVIEWS
Review of The Pragmatist Challenge: Pragmatist Metaphysics for Philosophy of Science. Edited by HK Andersen and Sandra D. Mitchell N Stamenković – 2025 – JSTOR
Review of Philip Davis, William James. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2022. J Torrance – 2025 – JSTOR
Review of Clifford S. Stagoll, Transforming One’s Self: The Therapeutic Ethical Pragmatism of William James P Stephens – William James studies, 2025
Review of Emma Sutton, William James, MD: Philosopher, Psychologist, Physician A Dianda – HOPOS, 2025
Review of Emma Sutton, William James, MD: Philosopher, Psychologist, Physician J Dunham – The British journal for the history of science, 2025
An interview with Alexander Klein
...James also thinks inquiry needs to be conducted in a scientific fashion, but especially in philosophical inquiry, he doesn't think this should be done using jargon, in a technical fashion. James's outlook here is evolutionary—he suggests that if natural selection operates on physical traits in populations of organisms, then a kind of selection may operate on ideas in an ecology of discourse. In the short-run, the ideas that proliferate may well be inferior in a host of ways to the ideas technical science produces. But on James's view, what counts in the long run (again, thinking especially of philosophy here) is the ideas that are adopted and passed along by *everyone,* not just by trained professionals. What makes those ideas true, for James, is that the ideas are in some sense adopted and carried forward by the entire community. And the entire community can't engage with ideas that can only be expressed in jargon.
So the case for James's account being the more promising pragmatist option when it comes to objectivity (at least in philosophy) rests on the relative size of the community of inquiry. On James's model, what's true is what sticks in the long run, from generation to generation, among all humans, not just the cognoscenti. It's obviously debatable whether biases and distortions are more likely to be canceled out in larger communities, but that's the (in my view not implausible) assumption on which Jamesean objectivity hinges...
Who was talking about capital letters?
“Diversity is a good; it just isn’t the only one. When competence isn’t the first criterion for appointments, everybody loses—including thos...
-
Anderson, ch-6-8; McDermott, ch8-10; Romano, Part 3. REPORT: Gary, Pragmatism & 12-step programs I jumped the gun on that question abou...
-
Anderson, ch9-11; McDermott, ch11-12; Romano, Part 4. REPORT: Erica , Women in Philosophy... See last time's questions pertaining to Rom...
-
Dr. Phil Oliver -- phil.oliver@mtsu.edu James Union Building (JUB) 300 Our course explores American philosophy in the context of American cu...
